Loading... Please wait...

Locations 2019

Miss Amy's Preserves can be found at these fine retail locations:

American Cheese
(631) 750-5202
289 Railroad Ave, Sayville

Tues - Wed 11 - 7pm
Thurs - Sat 11 - 9:30pm
Sun 11 - 7pm
Closed Monday

The south shore's number one all American made cheese shop!

Long Island Expressway Welcome Center

Long Island Expressway I-495 east bound side between Exits 53 and 52
Open 24 hours

Featuring, "A Taste of New York", the premier collection of exclusively made in New York gourmet foods.

Blue Point Brewing Co
(631) 475-6944
161 River Ave, Patchogue

Tasting room hours:
Wed-Fri 3 - 9pm
Sat 12 - 9pm

Look for Miss Amy's Blue Point Mustard, featuring whole seeds and the brewery's own Oatmeal Stout.

The Milk Pail Country Store
1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill

Mon, Wed - Fri 9:30 - 5:30pm
Sun 10 - 5:30pm
Closed Tuesdays

A Family Farm Tradition celebrating 38 years!

The Amazing Olive
(631) 307-9092
35 East Main St, Patchogue

Open 7 days, 10 - 6pm

A vast array of premium olive oil, balsamic vinegar and many other delicious gourmet foods.

Sag Harbor Baking Company
(631) 899-4900
51 Division St, Sag Harbor

For absolutely amazing special occasion cakes in both taste and look, go see the fine bakers at Sag Harbor Baking!



    There are no products in this category.

Sign up to our newsletter