Miss Amy's Blue Point Mustard is a hearty whole grained mustard that really packs a wallop! Yellow and black mustard seeds are soaked in Blue Point Brewery's Oatmeal Stout. Mixed with mustard flour and spices, this full flavored & heart healthy condiment is a must for any serious mustard lover! Try it on sandwiches and grilled poultry. Delicious with smoked fish on crackers. Stir into vinaigarettes and sauces for a spicy kick!
Cathy Asher (Submitted on 14th Apr 2023)
This is the best mustard I’ve ever had! I think that it’s the mustard seeds that make it stand out. My whole family loves it and I send it to them all over the country!
Bernard (Submitted on 27th Dec 2022)
The only thing I can say is that this is simply the best mustard I have ever tasted. After leaving Long Island eight years ago I still order it through the website. Thank yoh Amy
Bernard F Wendell Jr (Submitted on 25th Nov 2020)
I grew up in Philly, traveled abroad in the Navy, worked on Long Island for thirty-five years and returned to Philly upon retirement. I was exposed to Ms Amy's Preserves at a holiday flea market on Long Island, bought my first jar of Blue Point Mustard and have never before or since had anything close to this perfection. It is so good that it pairs with almost anything. I love it on my ground prime rib burgers and can't resist sampling it right out of your classy jars. The spicy bite and seeds popping in your mouth are experiences not to be missed. The cost is high and the shipping really increases the price but anything this good transcends price. Thank you Amy, I remain a loyal and tasteful customer!
Bernard (Submitted on 25th Apr 2018)
It is simply the best mustard I have ever tasted. A nice spicy bite and the explosion of the mustard seeds in your mouth is a singular experience everyone who likes mustard should experience. It is simply a party for your mouth.
Bernard (Submitted on 1st Feb 2017)
Seven dollars for mustard and seven dollars for shipping makes this small jar of blue point mustard fourteen dollars to me without tax....No mustard is worth fourteen dollars but this stuff is simply unique and I smile every time it touches my tongue. I will continue to pay fourteen dollars for my small jar of Blue Point Mustard and decide what else I will have to do without in my pantry. When you find the best, always retain that level as a minimum as long as you can. Blue Point Beer and mustard seeds make this an incredible treat. Thank You Miss Amy, you are special...
Robbin (Submitted on 17th Dec 2015)
This mustard is tastier and better than any whole grain mustard I have ever tried, whether from the US or France. You can really taste the bold flavors and the hint of beer is great. Highly recommend!
Unknown (Submitted on 23rd Nov 2015)
Of the approximately gazillion mustards on the market (not that we've tasted them all), this is our favorite. Wonderful taste and texture. We also love that it's hand made locally.
firstname.lastname@example.org (Submitted on 2nd Feb 2015)
I have been buying Miss Amy's Blue Point Mustard for 4 or 5 years in the summer at the farm stand I frequent. I would stock up for the winter, then I found you can order online! Game changer! I buy extra to sent to my daughter in Baltimore. We are all addicted to it. The Blue Point Beer gives it a very special tang that makes the flavor POP!